I've been through this entire thread hoping to find something without success. I don't have any screens or anything, just a vauge memory of a video I downloaded from here or another chan several years ago. I've also seen it on a site, possibly pronhub.

The video is two young (early 20s) frat boy types sitting on a couch in a semi-dimly lit room with an orange or reddish glow I believe. It seemed like it was being recorded from a table in front of them like they were filming it themselves or on webcam. I think they started clothed, eventually stripping and sucking each other but I don't remember them fucking. The most defining thing I remember was how authentic it felt, like they were best friends and really comfortable with each other but had never done this before and were really nervous.

If anyone can help me, I'd love you forever.