-  [WT]  [PS]  [Home] [Manage]

  1.   (new thread)
  2. [ No File]
  3. (for post and file deletion)
/phi/ - Philosophy
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG, WEBM
  • Maximum file size allowed is 1000 KB.
  • Images greater than 200x200 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Currently 484 unique user posts. View catalog

  • Blotter updated: 2011-01-12 Show/Hide Show All

There's a new /777/ up, it's /selfhelp/ - You're Pathetic, We're Pathetic, We Can Do This! Check it out. Suggest new /777/s here.

Movies & TV 24/7 via Channel7: Web Player, .m3u file. Music via Radio7: Web Player, .m3u file.

WebM is now available sitewide! Please check this thread for more info.

Anonymous ## Mod ## 11/10/26(Wed)10:01 No. 3905 ID: 4c1a8e [Reply] Stickied

File 13196161034.jpg - (71.49KB , 256x256 , slow.jpg )

For growing and shit or whatever I present to you:


Put in whatever resources that fit in here, whether it's from wikipedia, youtube, some university, or where ever. Just remember to keep it within the board's guidelines and rules.
Use it or lose it, faggots.

34 posts and 3 images omitted. Click Reply to view.
Anonymous 15/07/21(Tue)20:27 No. 12250 ID: 1e9d00

American Nihilist Underground Society
"Nihilism, Futurist Traditionalism and Conservationism"

I have found this to be a great positive influence on my life, not just philosophically/abstractly or in practical life matters, but also in the other things the site introduced me to. Got me into Nietzsche, Burroughs, and some pretty awesome metal bands I'd probably never have had heard of.

Anonymous ## Mod ## 12/02/02(Thu)05:26 No. 5920 ID: 4fb7fa [Reply] [First 100 posts] [Last 50 posts] Stickied

File 132815678430.jpg - (161.57KB , 500x452 , 6904084_Untitled-2.jpg )

This thread is for discussion of the validity of religion(s) and arguments for and against the existence of god/gods.

Any other new posts about this subject will be deleted, or locked and referred to this one.

New threads about religious concepts that play inside their own ruleset are allowed, and we kindly ask that you refrain from turning those well meaning threads into arguments about religion as a whole.

308 posts and 18 images omitted. Click Reply to view.
Anonymous 15/06/07(Sun)22:37 No. 12218 ID: 107312


An entity that we would describe as "God" would have no wants or needs as we know them. However, the concept of "God" very much has a "want" and a "need" for people to propagate it, because if they stop doing so the concept ceases to exist. A "God" would not care either way if people believe in it or not. The picture of God that lives in peoples' heads, however, fears being forgotten because that is death to it.

READ THIS BEFORE POSTING YOU PILE OF FAGGOTS Anonymous ## Mod ## 11/09/09(Fri)04:51 No. 2371 ID: 175f07 [Reply] Locked Stickied

File 131553668277.jpg - (24.94KB , 400x615 , formalblacktie2.jpg )

We interrupt your scheduled bickering for this important announcement: Understanding /phi/

  • What this board is:
    • A place to discuss epistemology, ethics, aesthetics, metaphysics, and logic, in a general sense, or in an applied sense (in sex, science, vidya, your mother).
    • A place where not only is being a pretentious, hubristic dickhead is allowed, but is considered the norm.
  • What this board is not:
    • It is not /b/, /x/, or /rnb/.
    • A place to spew incoherent nonsense and verbal diarrhea.
    • A place to make claims with no justifications (and "because I say so" or "because you're gay" isn't a justification).
    • A place where the global rules do not apply.
An inability to follow these conventions will result in a warning!
Repeat offenders will be banned!

Anonymous ## Mod ## 11/12/04(Sun)05:06 No. 4980 ID: 4c1a8e

Dear faggots,
I shouldn't have to remind you, but if someone is posting something against the rules, please report it.

If you don't know how to report a post, please see our super-sugoi FAQ section on the front page.

Thank you for your co-operation.

Anonymous 15/07/10(Fri)09:50 No. 12233 ID: 85377d [Reply]

File 143651465770.jpg - (143.75KB , 1920x1080 , rusttttt.jpg )

>eternal recurrence
>time is a flat circle
>in your darkest hour, a demon tells you your life is to be repeated
>again and again and again
>are you happy?

Anonymous 15/07/16(Thu)23:04 No. 12237 ID: 94219f

No, but then again maybe I was never meant to be.

Anonymous 15/08/14(Fri)10:52 No. 12263 ID: 18b905

I am neither happy nor unhappy. It doesn't matter. Unless I am somehow born each time with the memories from each previous life, I will always "die" at the end. From the perspective of the current me, there is no difference.

Anonymous 15/08/22(Sat)01:48 No. 12271 ID: 7d07df

I may be disappointed.

TeachingWRONG teachingwrong 15/07/17(Fri)19:09 No. 12240 ID: 5d8155 [Reply]

File 14371529898.jpg - (8.49KB , 225x225 , teachingwrong.jpg )

how do you teach "wrong"

for all ages.

as you're aware. our world is filled with rulers. professionals. bee's. losers. that have never learnt "wrong".

SHARE your IDEAS of how to TEACH the POWERS THAT BE, what being WRONG means and NECESSARY DISCIPLINE it's method.

2 posts omitted. Click Reply to view.
Anonymous 15/08/14(Fri)13:49 No. 12264 ID: 358f52

They learned what wrong was. People just don't fucking care. It's in our nature. When we think we can get away with bad shit that gives us an advantage 99% of the time we're gonna do it. When you've got lots of power and money, it's even easier to get away with that shit so they do it more.

Sure, you get some people who are better than others at not doing bad things and avoiding that temptation, but that's why we consider those people saints and hold them up as exceptional people rather than the norm.

Anonymous 15/08/19(Wed)17:48 No. 12269 ID: 5ba37e

File 143999933667.jpg - (24.83KB , 625x469 , gplus1559638302.jpg )

This site explains how to do it all wrong.
This is why merican kids are tarded now.
So much failure in this idiot led system.

Pic maybe related. Maybe not.

Anonymous 15/08/20(Thu)04:28 No. 12270 ID: ca3ceb

Guess my joke sucked.
OP is still a faggot.

circumventingSTUPID fearofstupid 15/08/14(Fri)21:30 No. 12265 ID: cb07aa [Reply]

File 143958064988.jpg - (87.33KB , 1000x1000 , youcantstopdumb.jpg )

Has anyone managed a way to PREVENT STUPID from BEING STUPID?

EVER ( really? honestly?)


we all know everything. just not usually at the same time. sorry for reminding me and you. we all know everything. remember that. remind me one day.

as for robo-sapiens. we all know what they think right now. bless. i had their manual installed years ago. this is for people who are actually really alive. not the "look for an opinion" take that cookie cut opinion from the "i think im alive" thought tree made by the arab zion.

the magic stick turns around...

"was this what you thought after my speech..."

heckler: "how do you know my opinions?"
Message too long. Click here to view the full text.

Anonymous 15/08/15(Sat)02:46 No. 12268 ID: 66f931

u schizo m8

Bible as Philosophy Anonymous 15/08/07(Fri)15:58 No. 12256 ID: a500ab [Reply]

File 143895591149.jpg - (95.31KB , 1600x965 , bible-Sunlight.jpg )

Isn’t... the Bible... just like the old philosophy plays of Plato and stuff... where they’d make up characters in parables and plays to explain the right way to act and the way the world worked... as opposed to the written word of a God nobody has ever seen

1 post omitted. Click Reply to view.
Anonymous 15/08/14(Fri)10:46 No. 12261 ID: 18b905

>characters in parables and plays to explain the right way to act

Exactly this, yes. They're no more significant or important than Aesop's fables. I like the way my school approached it; we studied the Bible in a Literature class.

fearofstupid 15/08/14(Fri)21:32 No. 12266 ID: cb07aa

bible is very violent.

dont read violence.

violence in violence out.

although the worst violence of all... prevention of violence... is the highest of all worst violences. obviously.

Anonymous 15/08/14(Fri)21:57 No. 12267 ID: 358f52

Depends. In reality? Yeah, that's basically what they are. But the way the people who came up with those stories saw it was that they were real. You don't find boring, droll genealogical trees in stories that people don't think are very real. It's clear that whoever came up with them originally tried to convey what they saw as the truth. It may not be true, but that doesn't make the lessons we can learn from The Bible any less relevant.

Just because they viewed it as something real doesn't mean we have to discard the whole thing. I don't buy it, and yet I still love reading stories from there. Proverbs and the Wisdom of Sirach being two of my main favorite books.

Anonymous 15/01/19(Mon)07:52 No. 11996 ID: 1b02b6 [Reply]

File 142165034863.jpg - (45.93KB , 600x600 , 1419480316512.jpg )

Worst place to ask since 99% of you couldn't even think of "letting go".

How do I let go of my ego? Or another way of asking is "how do I stop the desire to prove myself worthy among my peers?". It's totally unnecessary, and sitting at home alone I can comfortably say that it's doable and the mindset actually worth having, but when I leave the door I cannot stop myself from becoming a totally different person. That is, one who feeds off the facial expressions of another person and who constantly seeks their approval, or "good" facial expressions. I genuinely don't care what they think when I'm home alone at the end of the day but I guess I still do if I'm behaving this way.

In asking this I'm hoping to find that 1% who can genuinely relate to me and may have found a solution, or at least philosophical banters that put my mind in solace when I leave the doors. (The answer "just stop caring" isn't as easy as you might think).

18 posts and 1 image omitted. Click Reply to view.
Anonymous 15/07/17(Fri)21:24 No. 12243 ID: 68279b


The road branches and we have two choices, equally evil.

If we take the first path...yours...we do not use the conclusions or developments of other people;"Don't learn your ideas, make up your own." Taken to its logical conclusion, one would be sitting in a cave, unable to make fire or even work stone...because THOSE were someone else's ideas. You are doomed to live out your life like an animal.

So, everyone takes the second branch, embracing our modern culture, wallowing in the technical innovations given to us by generations of geniuses...and people's minds atrophy, they never think an original thought of their own, and they can only parrot the thoughts and deeds of others. The savage huddled in his cave is actually better off, and morally superior.


Become a Buddhist. Personally I think that all that 'Nirvana, the willing annihilation of the self' stuff is illogical, suicidal nonsense, but I am all for everyone having the freedom to hold their own views. As for me...I LIKE my ego.

Anonymous 15/08/04(Tue)06:24 No. 12254 ID: 9f811c

You just took a jab at anon's ego. That's funny to me.

Anonymous 15/08/12(Wed)09:29 No. 12259 ID: 3da235

Ever tried LSD?

Universally Preferable Behavior Anonymous 14/05/07(Wed)23:06 No. 11322 ID: 180d0f [Reply]

File 139949680123.jpg - (24.91KB , 300x350 , UPBbook.jpg )

An attempt to prove secular ethics.


"UPB in a Nutshell:

1. Reality is objective and consistent.

2. “Logic” is the set of objective and consistent rules derived from the consistency of reality.

3. Those theories that conform to logic are called “valid.”

4. Those theories that are confirmed by empirical testing are called “accurate.”

5. Those theories that are both valid and accurate are called “true.”
Message too long. Click here to view the full text.

5 posts omitted. Click Reply to view.
Anonymous 14/09/27(Sat)05:14 No. 11814 ID: 64cbb2

I live my life by the principal that something can only be true if it's logical, if someones stating a fallacy I'll flat out tell them they are, illogicity is entirely human;logic just is

Anonymous 14/09/28(Sun)00:16 No. 11822 ID: eb89c4

Not necessarily. Quantum mechanics for example violate some Logical laws and are still very much true.

Empirical Validation very much trumps Rationality in 100% of cases.

Anonymous 15/08/10(Mon)07:35 No. 12258 ID: d52e1d

this sort of nonsense intuitionism doesn't prove anything. you cannot prove the validity of a moral theory by appealing to our 'moral intuitions'. If anything it's just another Is-Ought problem.

It's basically making the case that because people intuitively feel that it would be 'bad' to push the fat man, that it we ought not push the fat man.

Pure nonsense.

Anonymous 14/03/02(Sun)05:26 No. 11146 ID: 600abd [Reply]

File 139373436128.jpg - (7.14KB , 225x225 , coconut head.jpg )

The other day in religion class, my teacher played a sermon about Catholicism and stuff. The shortest I could put it is, "If there was no god, then the universe would have had to started somewhere, the big bang per say. If we could use a computer and go look at that explosion, or a simulation of, we'd be able to figure out the rate at which the universe expands. From this we'd essentially be able to figure out the future and then life would be meaningless, because our choices would already have been determined."

Any thoughts on this? I thought it was a pretty interesting standpoint, but was probably worded confusingly in order to sound smart and force people to think you know what you're talking about...

27 posts and 1 image omitted. Click Reply to view.
EL+NEGRO 15/01/10(Sat)07:59 No. 11982 ID: f20e67

File 142087317732.jpg - (50.88KB , 900x900 , photo.jpg )

OP, I may be terribly wrong but I think that the theory of Big Bang does not attack Catholicism. I think that this theory was proposed by a Belgian Catholic priest called George Lemaitre. Also, in both mainstream Christianism and in Naturalism there is nothing that stops us from taking decisions by ourselves and not because destiny.

Anonymous 15/01/23(Fri)23:44 No. 12002 ID: c96350


1. If God is all powerful, he must be all knowing.
2. If he is all knowing, he knows the future absolutely.
3. If he knows the future absolutely, he knows the future of any given human being.
4. If he knows the future of any given human being, then that person does not have the ability to make choices which change that future.
5. If that human being doesn't have the ability to make choices which change the future, then free will does not exist.
6. Therefore, if God exists, free will does not exist.

Anonymous 15/08/04(Tue)08:48 No. 12255 ID: b3036a

As I see it, this falls apart at point 4
God simply knowing the future doesn't mean the future is set in stone or prevent others from being able to change the future, if anything it means that God would know the new future as soon as the path of events changes, or even beforehand, and he would know any changes possible to the future, so he could prevent changes if he wanted, but I don't see any reason to think that he does. God knows everything, so he CAN eliminate free will, but evidently chooses to let people choose. All powerful doesn't mean all controlling.

Delete post []
Report post